MAIN MENU
Appeals and Complaints Policy
Appeals and Complaints Policy
The Journal of Multidisciplinary Cases (JMC) is committed to fair, transparent and accountable decision-making. It handles appeals and complaints in line with the COPE guidance on appeals and complaints.
Appeals against editorial decisions
- Authors may appeal a rejection that they believe rests on a factual error, a misunderstanding of the work, a clearly flawed review or a conflict of interest. Write to the editorial office at editor.jmc@gmail.com within 30 days of the decision.
- State the manuscript ID, the specific grounds for appeal, and a point-by-point response to the reviewers' comments. Disagreeing with reviewers' scientific judgement alone is not a ground for appeal.
- The appeal is assessed by the Editor-in-Chief. If the Editor-in-Chief took the original decision, a senior editorial board member who was not involved assesses it instead. Either may seek an additional independent review.
- Authors receive the outcome and the reasons for it in writing, normally within 30 days. Only one appeal is considered per manuscript, and the appeal decision is final. The manuscript is not considered by another HM Publishers journal while an appeal is open.
Complaints
- Anyone may complain about the journal's processes, editorial handling, delays, publication ethics or the conduct of editors, reviewers or staff.
- Send complaints about reviewers, board members or staff to the Editor-in-Chief at editor.jmc@gmail.com. Send complaints about the Editor-in-Chief, or about HM Publishers itself, to the publisher at publisher@hmjournals.com, marked "Complaint".
- Every complaint is acknowledged within 7 working days and investigated by someone not involved in the matter complained about. The complainant normally receives a written response within 60 days.
- Allegations of misconduct, such as plagiarism, data fabrication, duplicate publication or peer-review manipulation, are investigated using the relevant COPE flowcharts. They may lead to a correction, an expression of concern or a retraction.
- If a complainant is not satisfied with the outcome, they may refer the matter to the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).